Why “Superpower” Language Falls Short in Neurodivergent Affirming Therapy

“ADHD is your superpower.”

You’ve probably heard it. Maybe in a training. Maybe from a parent in your office. Maybe you’ve said it to a client who was having a hard week and needed something hopeful.

I get why. As a neurodivergent clinician, I know how good it can feel to hear your brain described as something other than broken.

But I’ve come to believe superpower language is a trap. A kind one. Still a trap.

Why do people call ADHD a superpower?

For decades, the clinical story of ADHD and autism was a list of deficits. Inattention. Impulsivity. Social impairment. Restricted interests. Read most diagnostic criteria and you’d think neurodivergent people had nothing going for them.

Superpower language showed up to fight that story. It said: look at the creativity, the hyperfocus, the pattern recognition, the energy. Look at what this brain can do.

That impulse is right. Neurodivergent people deserve to hear about their strengths. Kids especially.

The problem is what the frame does next.

What is the supercrip stereotype?

Disabled activists have a name for this pattern. They call it the supercrip stereotype.

Sami Schalk (2016), a disability studies scholar, traces the term back to the disability rights movement of the 1970s. Activists used it to critique stories that celebrate disabled people only when they do something extraordinary. The athlete who “overcomes.” The genius whose disability is secretly a gift.

The late disability rights activist Stella Young pushed this further in her 2014 TEDx talk. (Bonus points for watching it!) She described “inspiration porn”: images and stories of disabled people used to make non-disabled people feel good. Her point was simple. Disabled people aren’t there to inspire you. They’re just living their lives.

Superpower language is a cousin of both. It tells neurodivergent people they’re worth celebrating because they’re special. Which quietly sets a bar.

And most people can’t clear it most days.

How superpower language shows up in therapy

It’s rarely dramatic. It’s usually tucked into kindness.

On intake forms that ask about “ND strengths” but have no room for the hard parts.

In parent sessions, where a worried parent hears “your child’s ADHD is a superpower” and leaves wondering why their kid still can’t get through a school morning without tears.

And with the clients who can’t find their superpower. I see this a lot. The adult who can’t hyperfocus on demand. The autistic teen whose special interest doesn’t impress anyone. The client who’s exhausted, burned out, and struggling to keep a job.

They hear “superpower” and conclude: I’m doing ADHD wrong.

That’s shame. We just handed it to them in nicer packaging.

What to say instead

The goal isn’t to swing back to deficit language. It’s to tell the truth.

Neurodivergent brains are different. They come with real strengths and real costs. Both are true at the same time, and the balance shifts depending on the environment.

Here are phrases I use.

At intake:

  • “What do you like about how your brain works? What makes life harder?”

  • “When does your focus work well for you? When does it fall apart?”

With clients:

  • “Your brain works differently. Some of it is hard. Some of it is great.”

  • “Some of this is hard because the world wasn’t built for you. Some of it is just hard. You don’t have to pick one.”

With parents:

  • “Your kid’s brain isn’t a gift or a problem. It’s theirs. Our job is to fit the environment to it.”

In treatment planning, swap “build on ADHD superpowers” for something concrete:

  • “Identify conditions where the client’s focus and energy work well. Build supports for tasks that drain them.”

Notice what these do. They make room for struggle without making struggle the whole story.

The antioppressive piece: moving the problem out of the person

Here’s what bothers me most about both frames, deficit and superpower.

They both keep the focus on the individual. Either your brain is broken and needs fixing, or your brain is magic and you need to live up to it. Either way, the person carries the weight.

The social model of disability offers another view. British disability scholar Mike Oliver (1983) helped popularize the idea that disability comes from the gap between people and environments built for someone else. A wheelchair user isn’t disabled by their legs. They’re disabled by the stairs.

For neurodivergent clients, the stairs look like eight-hour school days with no movement. Open-plan offices. Fifty-minute sessions with a talk-only format. Paperwork deadlines that assume a neurotypical executive function system.

There’s an equity issue here too. Notice who gets called gifted and who gets called defiant. Superpower stories tend to center neurodivergent people with privilege: white, financially stable, lower support needs, and able to turn their traits into something marketable. A Black ND kid with the same restlessness is more likely to get disciplined than celebrated.

Antioppressive practice asks us to look at the system before we look at the person. Superpower language, however well meant, skips that step.

Takeaways for clinicians

  • Swap “superpower” for honest language: different, with real strengths and real costs

  • Ask about strengths and struggles at intake, and leave room for both

  • When a client says “I can’t find my superpower,” treat it as shame to explore, not a goal to chase

  • Before treating a client’s struggle as their problem, ask what in the environment is making it harder

If you’re building your neurodivergent affirming skills this renewal cycle, grab my free WA CEU tracker. It keeps your hours organized so you can spend more energy on trainings that actually change your practice.

References


Oliver, M. (1983). Social work with disabled people. Macmillan.
Schalk, S. (2016). Reevaluating the supercrip. Journal of Literary & Cultural Disability Studies, 10(1), 71–86. https://doi.org/10.3828/jlcds.2016.5
Young, S. (2014, April). I’m not your inspiration, thank you very much [Video]. TEDxSydney. https://www.ted.com/talks/stella_young_i_m_not_your_inspiration_thank_you_very_much

Next
Next

What Neurodivergent Affirming Supervision Looks Like